New York City’s nightlife is legendary, and the cocktail scene is right at the heart of it. Checking out the top cocktail bars New York lets us dive into some pretty wild flavors and unexpected combinations, all thanks to bartenders who really know their stuff. Whether you’re after a tried-and-true classic or something a little offbeat, there’s a bar in this city that’ll hit the spot.
Wandering through the city’s maze of bars, you’ll notice that each spot has its own distinct energy—some are small and mellow, others are buzzing with life. The best cocktail bars in NYC aren’t just places to grab a drink; they’re places to slow down, catch up, and maybe even get a little lost in the moment. Whether you’re hunting for a hidden nook to chat or a scene-y spot to toast something big, you’re covered.
1) The Dead Rabbit
The Dead Rabbit pretty much defines the phrase “top cocktail bar.” This two-story hangout has a downstairs taproom that’s always lively, and an upstairs parlor that feels a little more refined. It’s kind of a mashup of old-school charm and modern flair—honestly, it works.
What really pulls you in is their menu, packed with vintage cocktails and some seriously good snacks. Every drink we tried felt like it was made with real care; you can tell the bartenders are proud of their craft. Even the food stands out, which isn’t always the case at cocktail bars.
The décor gives off a warm, almost nostalgic vibe, and if you’re lucky, you’ll catch some live music that keeps things upbeat. The staff here actually seem to enjoy what they do, which makes the whole experience that much better.
There’s something about The Dead Rabbit that just nails that Irish-meets-NYC spirit. If you’re into cocktails, you probably already have this place on your list—but if not, you should.
Rating: 4.7 (7582 reviews)
Location: 30 Water St, New York, NY 10004
Contact: (917) 540-5228
Website: Visit Website
2) Death & Co East Village
Death & Co East Village is one of those places that just oozes cool. The vibe is a little mysterious—think speakeasy, but without the pretension. The lighting is low, the décor is slick, and it’s the kind of spot where you could lose track of time nursing something strong and well-made.
The bartenders here are sharp and genuinely friendly, always happy to suggest something if you’re feeling indecisive. The cocktails themselves? Let’s just say there’s a reason people keep coming back. Every drink is balanced, and you can taste the thought that went into it.
Something we noticed—there’s a selection of bar tools and glassware for sale, which is a neat touch if you want to bring a bit of the experience home. And if you’re planning something special, they do private events too.
Honestly, Death & Co is a go-to for us when we want great drinks without any fuss.
Rating: 4.5 (1961 reviews)
Location: 433 E 6th St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (212) 388-0882
Website: Visit Website
3) Amor y Amargo
Walking into Amor y Amargo, you get hit with this cozy, almost secretive vibe. It’s tiny, but that just adds to the charm—perfect for a low-key night or a date where you’re actually trying to talk. The décor is understated but thoughtful, which I appreciate.
The menu leans into classic Italian flavors and bitters, so if you’re looking for something a little different, you’ll find it here. The bartenders are genuinely enthusiastic and love sharing the stories behind their creations, which makes the drinks feel even more special.
What really stuck with us was how much attention goes into every ingredient. These folks care about what they’re pouring, and you can taste it. It’s not just about the booze—it’s about the whole experience, and it shows.
If you’re in the mood for something out of the ordinary, Amor y Amargo should be on your radar.
Rating: 4.7 (911 reviews)
Location: 443 E 6th St, New York, NY 10009
Contact: (833) 328-4588
Website: Visit Website
4) Angel’s Share
Angel’s Share is a bit of a legend among New York’s cocktail bars. Tucked away in the West Village, it’s got that hidden, speakeasy feel that always makes you wonder if you’ve stumbled onto something special. The cocktails are inventive, and the whole place feels kind of magical, honestly.
Inside, it’s dim and elegant—exactly the kind of place you want to settle into for a few hours. The bartenders are pros who clearly love what they do, and their mixology skills are on full display. Fresh, sometimes unexpected ingredients pop up in the drinks, which keeps things interesting.
Heads up: they don’t take reservations, so you’ll probably want to show up early to snag a spot. Groups are capped at four, which keeps the vibe mellow and a little exclusive.
Special occasion or just a regular night out, Angel’s Share feels like a treat. The cocktails aren’t just drinks—they’re a little bit of theater, and you’ll probably be talking about them long after you leave.
Rating: 4.5 (1696 reviews)
Location: 45 Grove St, New York, NY 10014
Contact: Not Available
Website: Visit Website
Frequently Asked Questions to Top Cocktail Bars New York
There’s no shortage of classic bars and fresh new lounges in New York’s cocktail world. From Manhattan’s polished institutions to the West Village’s hidden gems, here are a few questions that pop up all the time.
What are the top-rated cocktail bars in Manhattan?
Some favorites: The Dead Rabbit and Death & Co East Village. Both are known for their killer drinks and memorable atmospheres.
Where can I find the best cocktail bars in NYC’s Midtown area?
Midtown has its share of gems. Angel’s Share stands out, offering a snug setting and classic cocktails that really hit the mark.
Are there any award-winning cocktail bars in New York City?
Definitely. Plenty of NYC bars have racked up awards for both drinks and service. The Dead Rabbit, for one, has earned some serious acclaim for its inventive approach.
What iconic cocktail bars should I visit in New York?
If you’re after iconic, you can’t skip The Dead Rabbit or Amor y Amargo. Both spots serve up not just great cocktails but also a sense of history you can feel as soon as you walk in.
Can you recommend upscale cocktail lounges in NYC for a sophisticated night out?
For something a little fancier, Death & Co is a solid bet. The setting is polished and perfect for a night when you want to treat yourself.
Where are the hotspots for innovative cocktails in the West Village?
The West Village has its fair share of spots where you’ll stumble across innovative cocktails. Take Amor y Amargo, for example—this place doesn’t shy away from bold flavors or unexpected twists in their drinks. If you’re after something a little different, it’s definitely worth popping in.
- Acclaimed photographers James and Karla Murray invite readers inside the doors of thirty legendary watering holes to discover how each has contributed to the social and cultural fabric of New York City
- For nearly three centuries, people have been gathering in New York City taverns, bars, and pubs
- A club in the back of a lingerie store, a Hare Krishna temple with a lunch canteen, a Mexican pulque bar in a Chinatown basement, a Central Asian eatery above the world’s largest diamond district, hole-in-the-wall countertops inside freight entrances, a Swiss ski chalet accessed through a kitchen, an open-to-the-public dining room in the United Nations, a celebrity-loved party spot inside a pawn shop, a dance destination behind a barber
- Over 100 pages of amazing decor, eccentric locations, bizarre food, newcomers, longtime holdouts and more that will please and astonish underground and post-industrial design buffs, refined gourmands, cocktail drinkers and anyone curious to discover more of the infinite ways to have fun in New York City
- This one-of-a-kind photo book offers evocative portraits of New York bars after closing time
- Daniel Root’s photos of New York bars at dawn are a perfect blend of beauty and melancholia
